Copyright

Copyright law cases

Copyright, District Courts, IP Law

Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. John Doe subscriber assigned IP address 108.21.214.248 — Court Grants Expedited Discovery to Identify Copyright Infringer via ISP Subpoena

The court grants Strike 3 Holdings’ ex parte motion for expedited discovery to serve a Rule 45 subpoena on Verizon Fios to identify a John Doe defendant accused of copyright infringement, subject to stringent protective conditions including a 60-day waiting period and ‘Attorneys’ Eyes Only’ restrictions.

Artificial Intelligence, Copyright, District Courts

Concord Music Group, Inc., et al. v. Anthropic PBC, et al. — Court Orders Meet and Confer on AI Output Copyright Claims After Hearing Reveals No Specific Infringement Allegations

The court expressed concern that the publishers’ briefing misrepresented their direct copyright infringement claim regarding AI outputs, because counsel admitted at the hearing that they sought to infer infringement of all 20,517 works merely from their inclusion in training data, without alleging a single specific instance of any work being reproduced as a Claude output.

Copyright, District Courts

Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. John Doe subscriber assigned IP address 107.222.122.96 — Court Grants Early Subpoena to Identify BitTorrent User in Copyright Case

The Southern District of California granted Strike 3 Holdings leave to serve a pre-Rule 26(f) subpoena on AT&T Internet to identify the subscriber behind an IP address accused of infringing twenty-four copyrighted films via BitTorrent, finding good cause under the Columbia Insurance framework and imposing privacy safeguards including a forty-five-day notice period and a limited protective order.

Copyright, District Courts

LIV Movies Ltd. v. Amazon.com, Inc. et al — Court dismisses contributory and vicarious copyright claims for failure to allege third-party direct infringement

The Southern District of California dismissed LIV Movies’ contributory and vicarious copyright infringement claims against Amazon because the amended complaint did not allege direct infringement by a third party, while leaving the direct infringement claim intact and granting leave to amend.

Copyright, District Courts, Trademark, Federal

Crafted by Joanna, LLC v. Solovev — Magistrate Judge Grants Motion to Enforce Discovery Order, Awards Fees, and Recommends Civil Contempt with Escalating Daily Fines

A federal magistrate judge in Kansas granted a motion to enforce a discovery order in a copyright and trademark infringement case, ordered the pro se defendant to produce Instagram sales records and pay $1,567.50 in attorney fees, and recommended that the district judge find him in civil contempt and impose escalating daily fines up to $1,000 per day until he complies.

Copyright, District Courts

Lopez v. Gonzalez et al — District Court Denies Copyright Damages Motion Without Prejudice for Failure to Specify Statutory Election and Provide Segregated Billing Records

The district court adopted a magistrate judge’s recommendation and denied a copyright plaintiff’s motion for damages without prejudice because the motion failed to reference the complaint’s election of statutory damages under 17 U.S.C. § 504(c), did not propose a specific amount within the statutory range, and lacked properly segregated billing records.

Copyright, District Courts

Rockefeller Photos, LLC v. Obaid Partners, Inc. — Court Grants Default Judgment but Reduces Statutory Damages from $630,000 to $15,750

The Eastern District of California adopted in part a magistrate judge’s recommendation and granted default judgment against a grocery store for infringing twenty-one stock photos, but rejected the requested $630,000 in maximum statutory damages as excessive and instead awarded the statutory minimum of $750 per image, totaling $15,750, plus injunctive relief, attorney’s fees, and costs.

Copyright, Fifth Circuit, Trademark, Federal

Shawn Thomas; The Tabletop Adventure, L.L.C. v. Leyline Publishing, L.L.C., doing business as Geek Therapeutics; Leyline Education, P.L.L.C.; Anthony Bean, PhD; Alicia Figliuolo — Fifth Circuit affirms summary judgment because a licensing agreement authorized use of the tabletop-game content

The Fifth Circuit affirmed summary judgment for Geek Therapeutics’ affiliated companies and personnel, holding that the parties’ second licensing agreement authorized use of Realms of Kymoria content and that the game developer’s remaining copyright, trademark, name-and-image, and unjust-enrichment arguments failed.

Copyright, Fifth Circuit, Trademark, Federal

Shawn Thomas; The Tabletop Adventure, L.L.C. v. Leyline Publishing, L.L.C., doing business as Geek Therapeutics; Leyline Education, P.L.L.C.; Anthony Bean, PhD; Alicia Figliuolo — Fifth Circuit affirms summary judgment because a licensing agreement authorized use of tabletop-game content and truthful creator credits

The Fifth Circuit affirmed summary judgment for Leyline, holding that the parties’ second licensing agreement authorized use of submitted Realms of Kymoria content, including unbilled content, and defeated the remaining derivative-work, trademark, name-and-image, and unjust-enrichment claims.

Copyright, District Courts

Strike 3 Holdings, LLC v. John Doe subscriber assigned IP address 96.255.206.30 — Court permits early ISP subpoena but restricts identification, discovery, and settlement contacts

The District of Maryland allowed Strike 3 to subpoena an internet provider before a Rule 26(f) conference, while imposing anonymity, confidentiality, limited-discovery, and court-supervised-settlement safeguards because an IP address does not necessarily identify the infringer.

Copyright, District Courts

Ahmed et al v. Uber Technologies, Inc. — Court Upholds Vicarious Copyright Infringement Claim Against Uber Eats but Dismisses Claims for Unregistered Foreign Works

The court denied Uber’s motion to dismiss the photographers’ vicarious copyright infringement claim, finding that allegations of pre-display review and contractual control over merchant-submitted photographs plausibly established the right and ability to supervise infringement, but granted dismissal of claims based on foreign works due to internally inconsistent allegations regarding first publication.

Copyright, District Courts

Fisher et al v. Meta Platforms, Inc — Court Orders Supplemental Briefing on DMCA Section 1201(a) Motion to Dismiss After Noting Recent Decisions Weigh Toward Denial

The Northern District of California, weighing four recent decisions from other courts that found plaintiffs had sufficiently stated claims under Section 1201(a) of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act regarding YouTube Technological Protection Measures, ordered the parties to file a joint supplemental brief on Meta’s pending motion to dismiss and continued the case management conference.

Copyright, District Courts, Trademark, Federal

BMW of North America, LLC and Bayerische Motoren Werke AG v. Ammar Issa, Rheingold USA, LLC, and Rheingold USA, Inc. — Court grants expedited discovery and orders defendants to show cause why they should not be held in contempt of a trademark and copyright injunction

The District of Utah found clear and convincing evidence that OBD Hawk was operating as a disguised continuance of Rheingold USA in violation of BMW’s permanent injunction, but ordered expedited discovery and a show-cause response before deciding civil contempt.

Copyright, District Courts

Nathan & Sons, LLC v. Larine, LLC — Copyright case transferred to the Southern District of Texas because doubtful personal jurisdiction made Colorado inconvenient and transfer favored a merits decision

The District of Colorado granted in part the defendant’s motion and transferred a copyright infringement and unfair-competition lawsuit to the Southern District of Texas, Houston Division, after finding that the action could proceed there, that Colorado was inconvenient because personal jurisdiction over the defendant was likely absent, and that transfer improved the chance the claims would be heard on the merits.

Copyright, District Courts, Right of Publicity

Cummings v. United States of America et al — Pro Se Copyright and Right-of-Publicity Claims Dismissed Without Prejudice for Violating Rule 8

The court dismissed a 95-page pro se complaint alleging copyright infringement and unauthorized use of the plaintiff’s likeness in the movie ‘Titanic’ because the pleading was too prolix, disorganized, and frivolous on its face to satisfy Rule 8, and denied all pending motions as moot.

Copyright, Tenth Circuit

The Capture Eleven Group v. Otter Products, LLC — Tenth Circuit dismisses copyright cross-appeals for lack of jurisdiction because the Rule 54(b) certification was conclusory

The Tenth Circuit dismissed cross-appeals from a multimillion-dollar copyright verdict because the district court’s conclusory Rule 54(b) certification did not adequately explain finality or why there was no just reason for delay, and it separately granted Otter’s motion to seal one appendix volume.

Copyright, District Courts

Steinarsdottir v. Tripscout — Travel Brand Directly Liable for Reposting Influencer’s Photos Through Overseas Contractors, but Lost-Sales Damages Fail

A D.C. federal judge granted partial summary judgment for an Icelandic influencer on liability for 52 reposts of her photos and videos by a travel company’s Instagram and TikTok accounts, holding that outsourcing the posting to overseas contractors does not avoid direct infringement liability, while rejecting her lost-sales damages theory and leaving other issues for a jury.

Copyright, District Courts

Timeless Production v. Vitvitskiy — Default Judgment Denied in YouTube Copyright and DMCA Counter-Notice Case for Lack of Jurisdiction, Standing and Damages Proof

A Northern District of California magistrate judge denied a $1.5 million default judgment against a Ukraine-based YouTube channel operator, because the video producer did not address personal jurisdiction, did not show it was the copyright owner who sent the takedown notices needed to sue under DMCA Section 512(f), and offered no evidence of damages.

Scroll to Top