District Courts

Federal district court decisions

District Courts, Utility Patent

GlaxoSmithKline v. Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna — Delaware Court Keeps Prosecution Laches Defense Alive in mRNA Vaccine Patent War

Judge Gregory Williams of the District of Delaware denied GlaxoSmithKline’s motions to dismiss prosecution laches defenses asserted by Pfizer/BioNTech and Moderna, finding the defendants plausibly alleged that GSK unreasonably delayed patent prosecution for over a decade and then broadened mRNA vaccine claims only after its rivals’ COVID vaccine technology became public.

District Courts, Trade Secret, Federal

Bayerische Motoren Werke AG v. Zync Inc. — Federal Judge Blocks ITC Trade Secret Proceeding to Enforce Forum Selection Clause

Judge Charles Breyer of the Northern District of California granted BMW a temporary restraining order blocking Zync Inc. from proceeding with an ITC trade secret investigation, finding BMW likely to succeed in enforcing a contractual forum selection clause designating German courts as the exclusive forum for disputes under their infotainment technology NDA.

District Courts, Utility Patent

MEMS Innovations LLC v. TDK Corporation — Court Dismisses Japanese Parent for Lack of Personal Jurisdiction in Piezoelectric Sensor Patent Case

Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley of the Northern District of California dismissed TDK Corporation of Japan from a piezoelectric MEMS patent infringement suit, holding that conclusory stream-of-commerce allegations were insufficient to establish personal jurisdiction and that plaintiff lacked a legitimate basis for naming the Japanese parent company as a defendant.

District Courts, Trademark, Federal

Watts v. Amazon Studios — Court Dismisses ‘The Love Zone’ Trademark Suit Over Amazon’s ‘Cross’ TV Series

A Southern District of New York judge dismissed a trademark infringement suit by New York radio host Maurice Watts against Amazon Studios over use of the name ‘The Love Zone’ in Amazon’s crime thriller series ‘Cross,’ finding no evidence that the fictional reference misled viewers about the source of the real radio show.

District Courts, Patent Subject Matter Eligibility

IngenioShare v. Epic Games — Patent for Multi-Platform Messaging Identity Struck Down Under § 101

A North Carolina federal judge dismissed a patent infringement suit against Epic Games (Fortnite) with prejudice, holding that U.S. Patent 10,142,810 — claiming a method for managing communications across services using a single user identifier — was directed to an abstract idea and lacked any inventive concept under Alice.

Scroll to Top