Background
Professional photographers sued Uber Technologies, Inc., alleging that their copyrighted photographs were uploaded to Uber's servers and displayed on the Uber Eats platform without authorization. The Second Amended Complaint asserted claims for direct copyright infringement and vicarious copyright infringement, alleging that Uber either directly copied the works through its employees or agents, or was vicariously liable for infringement committed by merchants who uploaded photographs to the platform. The photographers alleged that Uber operates Uber Eats as a curated commercial marketplace where food photographs are integral to generating commission revenue, and that Uber maintains a pre-display review process for all merchant-submitted photographs.
This was the second motion to dismiss in the case. The court had previously dismissed the original complaint's vicarious and contributory infringement claims, as well as claims related to foreign works lacking allegations regarding place of publication. After granting partial reconsideration, the court allowed the photographers to amend their vicarious liability claim. Uber then moved to dismiss the Second Amended Complaint, arguing that the vicarious infringement claim still failed to state a claim, that claims based on unregistered foreign works should be dismissed, and that requests for statutory damages and attorneys' fees for unregistered works should be stricken.
The Court’s Holding
The court denied Uber's motion to dismiss the vicarious copyright infringement claim. The court found that the photographers adequately pleaded predicate infringement by alleging that Uber's employees or agents reproduced, displayed, and distributed the photographs, or alternatively, that merchants committed the direct infringement. The court rejected Uber's argument that the photographers needed to identify specific individuals who uploaded specific photographs, finding that the alternative pleading style was permissible and provided fair notice of the claims.
Regarding the supervision and control element, the court found that allegations that Uber reserves and exercises the right to review, approve, reject, or remove any merchant-submitted photograph before or after display, combined with contractual rights to reject, remove, or modify uploaded photographs at any time for any reason, plausibly established both the legal right and practical ability to supervise infringing activity. The court distinguished cases where control mechanisms were impermissibly broad, finding that Uber's alleged pre-display review process was analogous to sufficient control found in other cases.
The court granted Uber's motion to dismiss claims regarding purportedly foreign works. The court found that Exhibit 2 to the Second Amended Complaint, which purported to identify foreign works and their countries of first publication, was internally inconsistent with the complaint's allegations. The exhibit contained website addresses rather than countries in the 'Initial Display Location' column, and the 'Published/Unpublished' column created irreconcilable contradictions about whether works were published before or upon upload. The court denied Uber's motion to strike the request for statutory damages and attorneys' fees, finding that the request was expressly limited to registered works and that striking was unwarranted after dismissal of the unregistered foreign works claims.
Key Takeaways
- A plaintiff can adequately plead vicarious copyright infringement by alleging in the alternative that either the defendant's employees or third parties committed the predicate direct infringement, without needing to identify specific individuals at the pleading stage.
- A platform operator's contractual right and practice of reviewing, approving, rejecting, or removing user-submitted content before display can establish the practical ability to supervise and control infringement necessary for vicarious liability.
- A direct financial interest in infringing activity exists where the infringement draws customers to the defendant's service and the defendant profits from increased sales, even if lawful content would generate similar benefits.
- Claims based on foreign works exempt from registration requirements will be dismissed when the complaint and its exhibits contain internally inconsistent allegations about the place and date of first publication.
- A request for statutory damages and attorneys' fees that is expressly limited to registered works will not be stricken when unregistered works have been dismissed from the case.
Why It Matters
This decision provides important guidance on pleading standards for vicarious copyright infringement claims against online platforms. The court's analysis clarifies that platforms implementing content review processes may face vicarious liability even without specific knowledge of infringement, and that plaintiffs need not identify specific infringing actors at the pleading stage. The ruling also demonstrates the importance of consistent allegations when claiming foreign works exemption from copyright registration requirements, as internal contradictions between a complaint and its exhibits can be fatal to such claims.
Your browser cannot display this PDF inline.
Download the full opinion (PDF)