BMG Rights Management v. Vetter — Supreme Court Quorum Failure Leaves Worldwide Copyright-Termination Ruling Intact

Case
BMG Rights Management (US) LLC v. Vetter
Court
Supreme Court of the United States
Judge
Not specified
Date Decided
October 19, 2026
Docket No.
25-1391
Topics
copyright termination, foreign rights, Supreme Court quorum, judicial recusal

Background

The dispute concerns the song “Double Shot (Of My Baby’s Love)” and a copyright rule that lets authors or their successors terminate certain earlier grants of rights after a statutory waiting period. Cyril Vetter’s side argued that the termination restored not only United States rights, but also rights outside the United States. The Fifth Circuit agreed in January 2026, treating the parties’ contingent foreign interests as part of the grant that the federal termination notice displaced.

Several music publishers, including BMG Rights Management, asked the Supreme Court to review that unusually broad territorial result. They argued that U.S. copyright law ordinarily stops at the nation’s borders and that a domestic termination notice should not reallocate copyrights created by other countries’ laws. The petition drew briefs from major entertainment-industry groups and copyright scholars because the Fifth Circuit’s rule could affect longstanding worldwide publishing arrangements.

But the Supreme Court could not reach the merits. Four Justices—Sonia Sotomayor, Neil Gorsuch, Amy Coney Barrett, and Ketanji Brown Jackson—took no part. With fewer than the six Justices required for a quorum, the Court used the special procedure Congress prescribed for that situation.

The Court’s Holding

In an unsigned order, the Supreme Court affirmed the Fifth Circuit’s judgment under 28 U.S.C. § 2109. That statute applies when the Court lacks a quorum and the qualified Justices conclude that the case cannot be heard and decided during the next Term. The resulting affirmance has the same effect in the case as an affirmance by an equally divided Court.

The order did not endorse the Fifth Circuit’s reasoning and created no new nationwide Supreme Court precedent on whether federal copyright termination reaches foreign rights. It instead left the lower-court judgment intact because the Court was institutionally unable to decide the petition. The practical result is nevertheless significant: Vetter keeps the benefit of the Fifth Circuit judgment, and that court’s worldwide-termination rule remains binding within the Fifth Circuit unless it is later revisited.

The distinction matters. A merits opinion could have resolved the territorial question for courts nationwide. This disposition settles the parties’ case without doing so, leaving courts outside the Fifth Circuit free to reject the Fifth Circuit’s approach and preserving uncertainty for publishers, songwriters, and licensees whose agreements allocate rights country by country.

Key Takeaways

  • A lack of the Supreme Court’s six-Justice quorum can produce an affirmance by operation of statute, without any ruling on the merits.
  • The Fifth Circuit’s holding that a U.S. copyright termination can recapture the disputed foreign interests remains effective and binding within that circuit.
  • The Supreme Court’s order does not establish a nationwide rule or signal agreement with the Fifth Circuit’s territorial analysis.
  • Parties structuring global copyright grants should account for the possibility that termination rights may be treated differently across jurisdictions and federal circuits.

Why It Matters

Copyright ownership is often divided by territory, time period, and type of use. If a U.S. termination notice can unwind foreign interests as well as domestic ones, the commercial consequences can extend across global royalty streams and licensing chains. The Fifth Circuit’s decision therefore has importance far beyond this particular song.

The unusual procedural ending also shows that an affirmance does not always mean the Supreme Court approved the decision below. Here, recusals prevented the Court from supplying a controlling answer. Rights holders must live with a consequential lower-court rule while the broader legal question remains open for another case with a workable quorum.

Surfaced via newsletter intake: Copyrightlaws.com.

Full Opinion

Your browser cannot display this PDF inline.

Download the full opinion (PDF)

Leave a Comment

Scroll to Top